The Paradoxical Law1

Neither the Honest Nor Dishonest Traveller Can Be Judged

The law of a certain land is that all who wish to enter the city are asked to state their business there. Those who reply truly are allowed to enter and depart in peace. Those who reply falsely are hanged.

What should happen to the traveller who, when asked his business, replies, "I have come to be hanged"?

Endnotes

 

1 from R.M. Sainsbury, Paradoxes (2nd ed.) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 145.).

Article Index | Profiles in the Law | Law's Great Documents | The Art of Law | Fabulous Law | Quotes | Blog